Top 8 Best Turkey Roasters for 2020

Roasted turkey is as classic and timeless a dish as it is delectable. We eat turkey to celebrate holidays, special occasions, and more and more lately, as just another great, healthy option that also provides us with wonderful leftovers for sandwiches, casseroles, salads, snacking, etc.

Best Turkey Roasters

A turkey, however, can be a challenge to cook because of its large size. Roasting a turkey usually involves giving up all our oven space for the majority of the day—something that can create additional problems on days like Thanksgiving when we are also trying to prepare several other dishes at the same time.

Plus, many of us just don’t have a roasting pan on hand that is large enough to handle such a big bird. And lastly, it’s not so easy to get the turkey to come out as well we would like it to—overly dry turkey is an all-too-common occurrence and the unspoken “elephant in the room” at many get-togethers.

A Better Option for Roasting Turkey

But there is another option that will free up your oven space as well as deliver consistent, satisfyingly delicious, juicy results—a turkey roaster. Turkey roasters are a countertop appliance specially designed for roasting turkeys to perfection as well as other meats and items that would normally require the use of your oven.

They provide better heat distribution than the oven, and their lidded design keeps in moisture and amplifies flavor.

A Better Option for Roasting Turkey

And, not only will you free up your oven for the preparation of other dishes, but turkey roasters also save you money—they use less energy and are more efficient than roasting a turkey in a traditional oven. Many models can accomplish the task more quickly than your oven as well.

It’s no surprise that turkey roasters have become very popular over the years. In fact, many home cooks nowadays consider them a must-have item. You might just feel the same way once you try one.

After all, what’s not to love about an appliance that saves you money, frees up your oven space, makes meal prep infinitely easier, and delivers perfectly roasted turkey every time?

What to Look for in a Turkey Roaster?

What to Look for in a Turkey Roaster

So, what do you look for when choosing a turkey roaster? Following are the properties we deemed most important:

1. Size

The roaster needs to be spacious enough to accommodate the largest size turkey that you anticipate roasting.

  • For some homes, an 18-quart capacity (up to a 24-lbs bird depending on the model) roaster may be suitable
  • And for others, a 22-quart capacity (up to a 28-lbs bird depending on the model) may be more appropriate

2. Construction Material

We preferred stainless steel elements to aluminum for its non-reactive properties, greater strength and durability, and coated materials (such as enamel) for easier clean up and non-stick properties.

3. Lid Shape

We looked for models that have a high, dome-shaped lid for size considerations, and lids that are designed to be self-basting, allowing the lid to stay on throughout the roasting time to keep the bird tender and juicy.

4. Heat Distribution

We found that roasters that emitted heat from the sides (or the sides as well as the bottom) yielded the best results.

5. Removable Base Pan

Removable Base Pan

We felt it was important to be able to remove the base pan from the roaster in order to make clean-up easier.

6. Rack and Lifter

We felt an elevated rack was essential to keep the turkey from cooking unevenly or braising in its own drippings, and with a lifter that enables you to easily remove the turkey from the roaster.

7. Dishwasher Safe

Dishwasher-safe pans, lids, and racks were also a plus.

8. Browning

We wanted a turkey roaster that browns well. Browned skin is important—more people fight over the skin at Thanksgiving than the wishbone!

9. Temperature Range

We preferred a turkey roaster that could achieve a high temperature (as much as 450 degrees Fahrenheit) as well as very low temperatures (150-200 degrees), making it a great tool to keep foods warm for an extended period of time.

10. Aesthetics, Quality, and Price

Style and appearance, overall quality, user reviews, and pricing are also important factors, as always.

Top 8 Best Turkey Roasters 2020

Taking all the criteria above into consideration, the following items were our top 8 picks for 2020:

IMAGE PRODUCT DETAILS

Oster

  • Capacity: 22 qt
  • Fit up: 26 lbs turkey
Check On Amazon

Oster

  • Capacity: 18 qt
  • Fit up: 22 lbs turkey
Check On Amazon

Hamilton Beach

  • Capacity: 22 qt
  • Fit up: 28 lbs turkey
Check On Amazon

Proctor Silex

  • Capacity: 18 lqt
  • Fit up: 24 lbs turkey
Check On Amazon

Nesco

  • Capacity: N/A
  • Fit up: 18 lbs turkey
Check On Amazon

Oster

  • Capacity: 16 qt
  • Fit up: 20 lbs turkey
Check On Amazon

Rival

  • Capacity: 22 qt
  • Fit up: 22 lbs turkey
Check On Amazon

Nesco

  • Capacity: 18 qt
  • Fit up: 22 lbs
Check On Amazon

1. Oster Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid – Best Overall

Oster Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid Review

This terrific turkey roaster from Oster took our top spot. Oster is a well known and trusted brand when it comes to appliances, and this one is no exception. It has everything we were looking for, including a sleek, stainless steel exterior that compliments any modern kitchen.

Pros

  • Size: This spacious roaster is a 22-quart capacity model which accommodates up to a 26 lbs turkey
  • Construction Material: The exterior surface as well as the removable pan are made from high quality, heavy duty, stainless steel. The pan has an enamel non-stick coating for easy clean up as well as the lid. The lifter rack is stainless steel
  • Lid Shape: Features a dome-shaped lid with a self-basting design to keep moisture in for an incredibly juicy, flavorful bird
  • Heat Distribution: The heating element on this model encircles the sides, providing exceptionally even heat distribution
  • Removable Base Pan: The roasting pan is removable for quick and easy clean up
  • Lifter Rack: Includes a sturdy lifter rack to easily insert or remove your turkey from the pan
  • Dishwasher Safe: The roasting pan, lid, lifter, and rack are all dishwasher safe
  • Browning: This model does an excellent job at browning
  • Temperature Range: This model ranges from a “keep-warm” setting of 150 degrees Fahrenheit all the way up to 450 degrees for excellent searing. Even includes a very handy “defrost” setting
  • Aesthetics, Quality, and Price: An attractive, high quality model with excellent user reviews and a good price for the value

Cons

  • Large, bulky appliance that takes up a good amount of counter space
  • Power cord on this model is short at only about 2 feet long
  • Outer surface gets very hot

2. Oster Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid – Best Smaller Size

Oster Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid Review

Our next pick is also a model made by trusted manufacturer, Oster. This slightly smaller, black enameled version features the same brand quality and is perfect for families that don’t need to roast quite as big of a turkey.

Pros

  • Size: This nice-sized roaster is an 18-quart capacity model which accommodates up to a 22 lbs turkey
  • Construction Material: The exterior surface as well as the removable pan and lid are high quality, heavy duty, black enameled steel. The enamel non-stick coating makes for easy clean up. The lifter rack is stainless steel
  • Lid Shape: Features a dome-shaped lid with a self-basting design to keep moisture in for an incredibly juicy, flavorful bird
  • Heat Distribution: The heating element on this model encircles the bottom and the sides, providing exceptionally even heat distribution
  • Removable Base Pan: The roasting pan is removable for quick and easy clean up
  • Lifter Rack: Includes a sturdy lifter rack to easily insert or remove your turkey from the pan
  • Dishwasher Safe: The roasting pan, lid, lifter, and rack are all dishwasher safe
  • Browning: This model does an excellent job at browning
  • Temperature Range: This model ranges from a “keep-warm” setting of 150 degrees Fahrenheit all the way up to 450 degrees for excellent searing
  • Aesthetics, Quality, and Price: An attractive, high quality model with excellent user reviews and a good price for the value

Cons

  • Large, bulky appliance that takes up a good amount of counter space
  • Power cord on this model is short at only about 2 feet long
  • Outer surface gets very hot

3. Hamilton Beach 28 lbs 22-Quart Turkey Roaster Oven

Hamilton Beach 28 lb 22-Quart Turkey Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid Review

This extra spacious model from renowned manufacturer Hamilton Beach accommodates the largest size turkey of any of our picks—up to 28 lbs. It also offers all the quality, functionality, and convenience of the best of our top picks.

If you are the person who always searches the turkey bin at the grocery store for the largest bird you can find, this one is for you!

Pros

  • Size: This extra spacious roaster is a 22-quart capacity model which accommodates up to a 26 lbs turkey
  • Construction Material: The exterior surface is very good quality, heavy duty, stainless steel. The removable pan is also steel and has an enamel non-stick coating for easy clean up. The lifter rack is stainless steel, and the lid is aluminum
  • Lid Shape: Features a high, dome-shaped lid with a self-basting design to keep moisture in for an incredibly juicy, flavorful bird
  • Heat Distribution: The heating element on this model encircles the sides, providing exceptionally even heat distribution
  • Removable Base Pan: The roasting pan is removable for quick and easy clean up
  • Lifter Rack: Includes a sturdy lifter rack to easily insert or remove your turkey from the pan
  • Dishwasher Safe: The roasting pan, lid, lifter, and rack are all dishwasher safe
  • Browning: This model does a good job at browning
  • Temperature Range: This model ranges from 150 degrees Fahrenheit all the way up to 450 degrees for excellent searing
  • Aesthetics, Quality, and Price: An attractive, good quality model with excellent user reviews and a good price for the value

Cons

  • Large, bulky appliance that takes up a good amount of counter space
  • Power cord on this model is short at only about 2 feet long
  • Outer surface gets very hot
  • Some users reported that this model did not brown as well as desired
  • Some users reported that the metal components were not as thick as desired
  • Some users reported that the enamel chipped fairly easily

4. Proctor Silex 32191 Roaster Oven

Proctor Silex 32191 Roaster Oven, Stainless Steel Review

This attractive turkey roaster from leading appliance manufacturer Proctor Silex was our runner up smaller size pick. This model is also an 18-quart version but is spacious enough to accommodate a slighter larger bird than the 18-quart Oster model thanks to its extra high lid design.

Pros

  • Size: This nice-sized roaster is an 18-quart capacity model which accommodates up to a 24 lbs turkey
  • Construction Material: The exterior surface is stainless steel. The removable pan is high quality, heavy duty, black enameled steel. The enamel non-stick coating makes for easy clean up. The lid is enameled aluminum. The lifter rack is stainless steel
  • Lid Shape: Features an extra high, dome-shaped lid with a self-basting design to keep moisture in for an incredibly juicy, flavorful bird
  • Heat Distribution: The heating element on this model heats from bottom, providing good heat distribution
  • Removable Base Pan: The roasting pan is removable for quick and easy clean up
  • Lifter Rack: Includes a wire lifter rack to easily insert or remove your turkey from the pan
  • Dishwasher Safe: The roasting pan, lid, lifter, and rack are all dishwasher safe
  • Browning: This model does a decent job at browning
  • Temperature Range: This model ranges from a “keep-warm” setting of 150 degrees Fahrenheit all the way up to 450 degrees for excellent searing
  • Aesthetics, Quality, and Price: An attractive, very good quality model with excellent user reviews and a good price for the value

Cons

  • Large, bulky appliance that takes up a good amount of counter space
  • Users reported that the power cord is too short
  • Outer surface gets very hot
  • Some users reported that this unit does not brown as well as the oven

5. NESCO ITR-01 Digital Infrared Upright Turkey Roaster – Best Upright Roaster

NESCO ITR-01 Digital Infrared Upright Turkey Roaster Review

We were very impressed with this innovative, high-speed, infrared upright turkey roaster from NESCO, which can cook an 18 lbs turkey in about two hours. The lifter on this is actually a removable, vertical cooking stand with a drip pan at the bottom.

We especially liked the lid on this model, which is glass—so you can see your bird as it cooks without having to lift the lid. And best of all, because of the upright design, the turkey browns on all sides, unlike traditionally shaped roasters that cannot accomplish that on the underside of the bird.

If you are a crispy skin lover, this might be the perfect choice for you!

Pros

  • Size: This upright roaster accommodates up to an 18 lbs turkey
  • Construction Material: The exterior surface is stainless steel with an enameled non-stick interior. The lid is glass for easy viewing
  • Lid Shape: Features a round glass lid
  • Heat Distribution: The heating technology on this model cooks the bird from the inside out, with very good heat distribution
  • Removable Cooking Stand with Drip Pan: The turkey mounts vertically on the cooking stand and the juices/fat are collected in a drip pan (attached to the stand) at the bottom
  • Lifter Hook: Includes a lifting hook that attaches to the cooking stand
  • Dishwasher Safe: The lid, cooking stand, and drip pan are all dishwasher safe
  • Browning: This model does a superior job of browning all the way around the bird, much like a rotisserie (although this does not rotate)
  • Temperature Range: This model has two temperature settings: high, which is 500 degrees, and low, at 300 degrees
  • Aesthetics, Quality, and Price: An attractive, nice quality model with very good user reviews and a good price for the value

Cons

  • Large, bulky appliance that takes up a good amount of counter space
  • Limited temperature settings do not allow for as much versatility as other models
  • Not self-basting
  • Outer surface gets very hot
  • The drip pan is fairly small and awkward—users reported that you need to be very careful to avoid spillage when lifting out
  • You cannot stuff your turkey
  • Turkey size is more limited than other models
  • Limited to only roasting meats that you can mount on the stand

6. Oster Smoker Roaster Oven – Best Roaster with Smoking Capabilities

Oster Smoker Roaster Oven, 16-Quart, Red Smoke (CKSTROSMK18) Review

We couldn’t resist slipping in one more turkey roaster model into our list from Oster. Though this one doesn’t have quite the same size capacity as other roasters, it does offer the same high quality we expect from Oster, and this one has a very desirable extra featureit can be used as a smoker.

If you love smoked turkey and don’t require the larger capacity, this is a great choice!

Pros

  • Size: This turkey roaster is a 16-quart capacity model which accommodates up to a 20 lbs turkey
  • Construction Material: The exterior surface as well as the removable pan and lid are high quality, heavy duty, enameled steel. The enamel non-stick coating makes for easy clean up. The rack is stainless steel
  • Lid Shape: Features a dome-shaped lid
  • Heat Distribution: The heating element on this model encircles the bottom and the sides, providing exceptionally even heat distribution.
  • Removable Base Pan: The roasting pan is removable for quick and easy clean up
  • Rack: Includes a sturdy rack
  • Smoking Functionality: Can be used outdoors as a smoker and includes side pockets where you slid in the wood chips of your choice (no lighting required)
  • Dishwasher Safe: The roasting pan, lid, lifter, and rack are all dishwasher safe
  • Browning: This model does a very good job at browning
  • Temperature Range: This model ranges from 50 degrees Fahrenheit all the way up to 450 degrees for excellent searing
  • Aesthetics, Quality, and Price: An attractive, high quality model with excellent user reviews and a good price for the value

Cons

  • Large, bulky appliance that takes up a good amount of counter space
  • Power cord on this model is short at only about 2 feet long
  • Outer surface gets very hot
  • Lid is not self-basting
  • Smoker function is for outdoor use only
  • Rack does not have handles which makes lifting a bit more awkward
  • Some users indicated that they would prefer an extra tier to the rack for the purpose of increasing the smoking capacity (some engineered their own)
  • Smaller than most turkey roasters

7. Rival Turkey Roaster Oven – Best Budget Pick

Rival Turkey Roaster Oven, 22-Quart, Black Review

This well-reviewed turkey roaster by Rival has many of the great features we were looking for. It features a classic black enameled design that just might be the perfect complement to your kitchen’s décor.

Pros

  • Size: This nice-sized roaster is a 22-quart capacity model which accommodates up to a 22 lbs turkey
  • Construction Material: The exterior surface and removable pan is good quality, black enameled steel. The enamel non-stick coating makes for easy clean up. Lifter rack is stainless steel
  • Lid Shape: Features a dome-shaped lid
  • Heat Distribution: The heating element on this model heats from the sides, providing very good heat distribution
  • Removable Base Pan: The roasting pan is removable for quick and easy clean up
  • Lifter Rack: Includes a removable lifter rack for easy insertion and removal
  • Dishwasher Safe: The removable roasting pan, lid, and rack are dishwasher safe
  • Browning: This model does a fair job at browning
  • Temperature Range: This model ranges from a setting of 150 degrees Fahrenheit all the way up to 450 degrees for excellent searing
  • Aesthetics, Quality, and Price: An attractive, good quality model with excellent user reviews and a very good price for the value

Cons

  • Large, bulky appliance that takes up a good amount of counter space
  • Users reported that the power cord is too short
  • Outer surface gets very hot
  • Some users reported that this unit does not brown as well as the oven
  • Lid is not self-basting
  • Some users mentioned that interior pan edges were sharp and required caution

8. NESCO MWR18-14 Roaster Oven

NESCO MWR18-14 Roaster Oven Review

Rounding out our list of favorites is this nice turkey roaster from NESCO. While pricing on most of our choices on the list didn’t exceed $100, this attractive white-enameled model packs in a lot of features for an especially budget-friendly price under $70, making it a great value.

Pros

  • Size: This nice-sized roaster is an 18-quart capacity model which accommodates up to a 22 lbs turkey
  • Construction Material: The exterior surface and removable pan is decent quality, white enameled steel. The enamel non-stick coating makes for easy clean up. Lid is aluminum and coated on the outside only. The lifter rack is chrome-plate
  • Lid Shape: Features a dome-shaped lid
  • Heat Distribution: The heating element on this model heats from the sides, providing very good heat distribution
  • Removable Base Pan: The roasting pan is removable for quick and easy clean up
  • Lifter Rack: Includes a removable lifter rack for easy insertion and removal of the turkey
  • Dishwasher Safe: The removable roasting pan, lid, and lifter rack are dishwasher safe
  • Temperature Range: This model ranges from a setting of 200 degrees Fahrenheit all the way up to 450 degrees for excellent searing
  • Aesthetics, Quality, and Price: An attractive, decent quality model with excellent user reviews and a very good price for the value

Cons

  • Large, bulky appliance that takes up a good amount of counter space
  • Users reported that the power cord is too short
  • Outer surface gets very hot
  • No information regarding browning capabilities was listed
  • Lid is not self-basting
  • Some users mentioned that lid material was too thin and lightweight
  • Some users reported durability issues

Conclusion

The turkey roaster oven is an appliance whose time has come—no modern kitchen is fully equipped without one. We’ve included some great options, and no matter which one you ultimately choose, you are bound to have great results and a new, versatile kitchen appliance you might just wonder how you got along without for so long!

 

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.