Best 4-Slice Toaster Reviews 2019 – Top 6 Recommended

I don’t know about you, but I like toast. Sweet, simple toast okay and we can add in a bagel or two along the way. The warmth of the bread the melted butter and possibly some preserves what’s not to love.

I’ll tell you what’s not to love the toaster I have had more toast ruined due to a faulty toaster than I care to admit too. It should be a simple thing just heat up the toast and pop up not too hard but here’s where things can go bad.

Either the temperature setting on the toaster is inaccurate or hard to understand, or the toaster doesn’t pop the toast up enough for you to be able to retrieve it, at least safely.

Best 4 slice Toaster

For the new year, I have decided to do some in-depth research into different brands of toasters to see if there is a toaster on the market that is worth purchasing and what they have done to solve some of the aforementioned toaster issues.

6 Best 4-Slice Toaster Reviews for 2019

ModelColorOur Rating
Cuisinart CPT-180 Brushed Stainless4.0
Cuisinart CPT-142 CompactWhite3.8
Hamilton Beach 4 Slice Long SlotSilver with Black3.5
KRUPS KH734D Breakfast Set 4-Slot Toaster DBrushed and Chrome Stainless Steel 3.8
KitchenAid Kmt4115cu 4-Slice ToasterContour Silver4.1
SunBeam Wide Slot 4 Slice Toaster 39111Black3.5

Let’s examine some details on each of these toasters and help you better understand why they made the short list.

1. Cuisinart CPT-180

Cuisinart CPT-180 Review

Cuisinart has been making quality kitchen appliances since 1971 and has become one of the leading name brands in countertop appliances.

With the availability in seven different colors to accent the brushed aluminum or chrome body, you are sure to find the right color for your kitchen.

Featuring large easy to read and understand temperature nobs this toaster has an almost retro look to it and will help add a touch of style to any kitchen.

As far as the ability to make toast this is where the Cuisinart CPT-180 seems to edge out competitors. The Cpt-180 offers you multiple features including reheat, defrost and bagel settings to choose from.

Now let’s talk about the toasting function of this model. For regular toast, you simply use the shade control settings to dial in that perfect shade. The dual control feature allows you to choose separate toasting levels for each side. This allows you to make perfect toast for multiple family members at the same time.

The bagel feature allows you to toast only the top of the bagel for a crunchy top and chewy bottom, like your bagel extra crunchy just toast it like you would bread and don’t use the bagel button. This toaster offers slots wide enough to handle a bagel but has self-adjusting guides to keep any bread in the perfect spot for optimal toasting.

You can defrost or reheat with this unit, and the extra wide slots make this toaster versatile enough to handle any type of thick bread.

The defrost feature works great for things like frozen waffles or pancakes and using this feature won’t overcook them or allow them to burn.

The reheat feature will allow you to reheat a piece of toast without it getting overdone.

Cuisinart has also given this toaster a high-lift lever that allows you to manually lift the bread higher to easily and safely get your toast out of the toaster.

Recommended for: Those who are looking for a quality toaster from the leading name brands in countertop appliances.

Things to like about it

  • It’s like two toasters in one unit.
  • The high -lift lever means no sticking a utensil in the unit to get the toast out.
  • It has extra wide slots to accommodate bagels.
  • It has a retro design for a fun look and is available in 3 colors.
  • Custom control features.

What not to like

  • There were a few complaints about the bagel button not working as described.
  • The toaster is a little pricey.

2. Cuisinart CPT-142 Compact

Cuisinart CPT-142 Compact Review

This compact little 4 slice toaster lives up to the Cuisinart name. This is an upgraded version of the classic toaster. Offered with a white plastic body and simple, clean design this toaster has some high dollar toaster features.

Like some of the larger toasters offered by Cuisinart, this compact toaster can turn out some pretty amazing toast.

The self-adjusting guides allow for a multitude of bread thickness, and the wide slots easily allow you to toast a bagel.

It offers a bagel button, defrost, and reheat functions just like it’s big brother has. Having seven browning shades and extra wide slots with dual toasting controls.

The dual toasting controls mean you can make two different shades of toast at the same time, and with seven shades to choose from you can find one to please everyone in the family.

Defrost and reheat allow you to toast frozen waffles or pancakes perfectly, and the reheat function can rewarm them without overdoing it.

The high-lift lever and crumb tray also comes standard on this compact countertop space saving toaster.

Recommended for: Those who are looking for a compact little 4 slice toaster with a white plastic body and simple, clean design.

Things to like about it

  • It has a plastic body, so it is lighter than metal toasters.
  • It comes only in white, so you don’t have to think about color matching.
  • It has custom control features similar to larger more expensive toasters.
  • It is smaller and more compact than some other 4 slice toasters.

What not to like

  • There were a few complaints that the toaster was not consistent.
  • Some said the exterior gets hot to the touch.

3. Hamilton Beach 4 Slice Long Slot

Hamilton Beach 4 Slice Long Slot Review

This is a different type of 4 slice toaster with a completely different look as a typical 4 slice toaster. Hamilton Beach is a well-known manufacturer of small countertop kitchen appliances, and they have introduced this sleek, and slim 4 slice toaster to there multi-model toaster line.

What makes this toaster different than the other 4 slice toasters in this article is that this one only has two slots. Now, these slots are long enough to accommodate two regular size pieces of bread in each one making it a 4 slice toaster with a twist.

The advantage that having long slots is that you can toast whole slices of Artisan bread, and won’t need to cut them in half.

The slots are wide enough to handle a bagel, and the inside guides adjust to the width if the bread so thicker slices of bakery bread are not a problem for this toaster.

It does offer a bagel button and also has seven shade settings so you can find the one that’s just right for you.

This toaster features the stay warm feature that will not over toast your bread and has an audible tone to alert you when it’s done.

It also features a High-lift lever and anti-jam feature that automatically shuts the toaster off if something were to become jammed, and a dishwasher safe crumb tray for easy cleanup.

Recommended for: Those who are looking for a sleek, and slim 4 slice toaster to there multi-model toaster line.

Things to like about it

  • It has a unique look.
  • It can accommodate long slices of bread.
  • It has a cool walls feature to keep the outside of the toaster cool to the touch.
  • It has an audible tone to alert you.

What not to like

  • It’s a little pricey.
  • Some complaints that the toaster beeps too often.
  • The design of this toaster makes it longer so it may not fit well on your countertop.

4. KRUPS KH734D Breakfast Set 4-Slot Toaster

KRUPS KH734D Breakfast Set 4-Slot Toaster Review

Krups has been creating countertop kitchen appliances since it was founded in 1846. Known as an innovator and creator of quality, precision products.

The Krups KH 734D is another one of these appliances. This toaster offers a modern design and is available in brushed chrome stainless steel that just looks good on the counter.

It offers six settings for browning and has easy to read dials. The KH734D comes ready to take on a multitude of toasting jobs and has a high lift lever for easy removal.

This unit offers blue LED lights to confirm your selection and offers easy to read shade selector dials.

This toaster has buttons on the front to assist you in choosing what you want to do with your bread or bagel.

You can select the level of browning independently for each side making this unit two toasters in one.

Press the bagel button for a perfectly toasted bagel, or the defrost or rewarm button for added control of your toasting.

The defrost and rewarm features allow you to toast frozen breakfast items perfectly and the rewarm button does just that it reheats your toast without overdoing it.

This model also offers dual removable crumb trays and storage for the cord to help keep the countertop tidy.

Recommended for: Those who are looking for an innovator and creator of quality, precision products.

Things to like about it

  • It has a stainless steel outer body.
  • It has a very modern look to it.
  • It has a 2year worldwide warranty.
  • It has extra wide self-centering slots.

What not to like

  • It is available in only this one chrome /stainless color.
  • It is a little larger than similar models.
  • It is the most expensive one in this review.

5. KitchenAid Kmt4115cu 4-Slice Toaster

KitchenAid Kmt4115cu 4-Slice Toaster Review

KitchenAid is well known in the countertop appliance world. Best known for their stand mixers however all of their kitchen appliances are top notch, and that includes this toaster.

This toaster has similar features to the other toasters like the bagel feature and high lift lever, but it has fewer settings than some and is limited to making just toast and bagels.

It does offer dual temp controls so that you can control the browning level on each side independently and has five different browning settings, but no defrost or reheat functions.

It does do an awesome job at making good and evenly browned toast, and offers plenty of shade variances. However, the bagel button only cuts the heat down on one side by 50% so the bottom of your bagel could be a little more toasted than you like.

This toaster is modern looking and available in three color choices. It offers an easy to remove crumb tray and a stowaway cord for convenience.

Recommended for: Those who are looking for a countertop appliance world with simple settings.

Things to like about it

  • It has a modern look to the design.
  • It’s simple to use.
  • It has an all-metal
  • It offers extra wide slots.

What not to like

  • It has fewer features than some of the other toasters in this price range.

6. SunBeam Wide Slot 4 Slice Toaster 39111

SunBeam Wide Slot 4 Slice Toaster 39111 Review

This is a simple toaster with classic looks and comes in a shiny black plastic body that will look good on any countertop.

SunBeam toasters have been around for decades and consistently make good toast. This unit has a button for toasting the perfect bagel and offers seven browning temperatures so that you can find that perfect shade of toast.

It offers separate toast control features so you can have different toasting levels going at the same time.

The self-adjusting guides keep your bread in the center for even browning, and this unit offers extra wide slots.

This unit also offers an anti-jam feature and high lift lever to make retrieving your toast a little safer.

Recommended for: Those who are looking for aa simple toaster with classic looks.

Things to like about it

  • It has a simple design.
  • It comes in classic Black.
  • It has a lightweight plastic body.
  • It has a classic look to t.

What not to like

  • It has limited features.
  • The cord attaches to the front corner and could be inconvenient.

Things to Consider Before Buying a 4- Slice Toaster

Choosing a 4- Slice Toaster

1. Do you need your toaster to perform multiple tasks?

With the advancement of technology, a toaster can do way more than just toast a piece of bread. It can rewarm toast without burning it; It can be used to toast frozen breakfast pastries. It can also toast only one side of a bagel. These options and some others are available on many different models.

2. Do you need a specific size of a toaster?

Only you can answer the question of how much counter space you have available for a toaster. This alone may put some toasters out of consideration for you.

When looking at different models keep this in mind, and this may help you decide between a full size or compact toaster.

If you do need a smaller size toaster, you still should be able to find one with all the features you are looking for.

3. How much do you want to spend on a toaster?

Toasters like many other small kitchen appliances come in a wide price range. Some toasters you will find have fewer features but are also sometimes less expensive.

This may not always be the case though, and you need to make certain to comparison shop.

4. What color and design do you want?

Many different designs for toasters exist. Some of them look like they are from the future and others look like they are from the past.

Having an idea of the style, not just the color when you are looking at toasters will help you save time by eliminating ones that won’t fit the style you are hoping to achieve in your kitchen.

Is your kitchen a modern design with lots of stainless steel and black? Or does it have a quaint and comfortable look that lends itself to color? These are a few things to keep in mind when selecting a toasters color and design.

Now put all of these things together, and you should be able to purchase a 4-slice toaster that will keep you satisfied for years to come.


You can decide what the best 4-Slice toaster is for yourself depending on what your specific needs are. Our review provides a guide to help you better understand the features and designs of some of the top 4-slice toasters on the market today.

With these 4-slice toasters, you can eliminate the frustration of burnt or undercooked toast, and even add some features that you didn’t know a countertop toaster could provide.

However, I think that the toaster that providers the most toast for your buck is the Cuisinart CPT 180 it offers abundant features for a reasonable price. It also offers the most color variety and has a classic look that could easily look at home in either a modern or classic kitchen.


We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.